D'Angelo Russell could quickly force Mavericks into a controversial trade

The Dallas Mavericks begin the 2025 season with plenty of star power, but they also have questions about their roster. Anthony Davis and Kyrie Irving lead the team, but the guard rotation is uncertain. This is where D’Angelo Russell becomes important, as his performance could determine whether Dallas makes a controversial roster move.

Russell's arrival in Dallas drew mixed reactions. Known for inconsistency, he has shown flashes of brilliance but has also struggled in big moments. The Mavericks signed him to stabilize the backcourt, especially with Irving expected to miss time. If Russell plays well, Dallas might stay patient. If he struggles, pressure to add another guard could become unavoidable.

Dallas’ guard depth seems thinner than it appears. While Russell, Dante Exum, and a healthy Irving provide options, there are still concerns about balance. Exum contributed reliably last season with strong defense and smart playmaking, but his role expands significantly if Irving is out. That leaves Russell carrying more responsibility than expected.

D'Angelo Russell's play could determine Mavericks' trade plan

Exum deserves credit for carving out a niche in Dallas. After a rocky start to his career, he became a versatile defender who can guard multiple positions and space the floor on offense. His ability to push the pace, hit open threes, and provide toughness made him a fan favorite. Still, he fits best as a complementary guard rather than a primary offensive leader. That’s why Russell’s steadiness at point guard is crucial.

If Russell starts strong, the Mavericks may choose patience, relying on him and Exum to manage the backcourt until Irving returns. This would maintain roster flexibility and preserve assets, such as draft picks and tradable contracts. But if Russell underperforms, Dallas could feel pressured to explore trades before the deadline. One option might involve trading a key piece, such as Daniel Gafford, for guard help, a deal that would spark controversy given Gafford’s vital role in the 2024 Finals run.

The consequences of such a move would be significant. Trading a dependable big like Gafford would weaken Dallas’ front-court depth and rim protection, areas that already need careful management with Davis’ injury history. Giving up a long-term asset for a short-term guard fix could backfire if Russell finds his rhythm later in the season. This is why the Mavericks must be cautious, balancing the risk of overreacting with the danger of wasting a season due to uneven guard play.

Russell knows this season could be a turning point in his career. He’s often seen as a player who thrives in the regular season but falters in the postseason. In Dallas, he has the chance to prove he can run the offense, hit timely shots, and defend at a level that lifts a contender when its second star is unavailable. His performance could be the difference between stability and chaos for the Mavericks.

The overall picture is clear: Russell’s play at the start of the season will impact more than just the guard rotation. It could shape whether the front office keeps the current core intact or pursues a divisive trade that alters the roster. With so much on the line, every game Russell plays in the early months will carry added significance.